One Standard
Posted in Bed Comforter Sets on 11/22/2004 03:57 am by admin
Noakhali Dialect: Its Prospect of Standardization
Ronald Wardough(1986) in his book “An Introduction to Sociolinguistics”(30) explanatorily presents R.T.Bell’s (1976) list of seven criteria of standardization:vitality, historicity, autonomy, reduction, mixture and de facto norms which separate dialect , a variety of language, from the standard language. The standard variety of a language is given some legal or very close to the legal status in a specific territory being marked as the utmost appropriate variety of a language which in
usual cases, is the language variety of the capital city defining selective markers of some specific region and class and is rejected by others for having the written texts maintaining the norms of spelling and grammar. On the other hand, a reduced in status or recognition of a regional or social variety of a specific standard language is a dialect distinct from other languages with the phonological, grammatical and lexical differences. It contains corresponding distinguishing accent.
Scholars of sociolingustics claim with valid grounds that a dialect can be given the status of a standard language variety of a country provided certain sociopolitical linguistic conditions are
attributed. My present paper is a sketchy examination of the prospect of the standardization of Noakhali dialect (a dialect of Bangla dominant in the south-eastern Bangladesh) in Bangladesh. An extract of a very recent Bangla novel written in the standard Bangla by a contemporary popular Bangla novelist Humayun Ahmed is presented here in its original standard form, then in its linguistic transformation into Noakhali dialect along with its English translation( for the better fascilitation of comprehending its meaning)as the primary material of the respective inquiry followed by the analysis of the prospective standardization of Noakhali dialect in Bangladesh.
The Romanized Original Standard Bangla Form of the Extract:
“Amar babar nam Moinu Mia.Khubi hashshokor nam.Kath mistri ba dorjider arokom nam
thake.Amar dadajan dorji chilen,abong tini tar moto korei cheler nam rekhechen.Tini
shopneo bhabenni ,tar chele girai hishab na kore nenometre ,picosecond-e hishab korbe.
Amar baba Moinu Mia Dhaka bishwabiddaloie folito podartho biddar oddahapok hishebe
jibon shuru korben.
Akhon oboshsho tar nam Moin Khan.Seceond year e porar shomoi-e tini prothom srenir
magistrate-er kache affidavit kore nam bodlechen.Tobe tar rokte dorjir je baparta poitrik shutre chole asheche ta akhono ache.Amar baba Moin Khan bishshwabiddaloi- er chakri
chere garments er karkhana diechen.Garments er nam “Mrimmoi Apparels”.Mrimmoi amar
nam .Bhalo nam Mrimmoi,dak nam Mri.Amar bhabte khubi kharap lage je ,bideshi lokjon
babar garments factory-r shirt gae die ghure barachche.Tader gharer shonge je sticker lege
ache shekhane likha Mrimmoi.Oachena manusher gaer ghamer gondhe amake bash korte
hochche.”
(Mrimmoi,by Humayun Ahmed,2003)
The Romanized Noakhali Version of the Extract:
“Ar bafer nam Moinu Mia.Akkere ashoinna nam.Aicha nam kadmistiri ar dorzigo oi.Ar
dadazan dorzi osil ar haten hatener huter nam hatener moto kori rakhse.Haten shopneto
sinta koreno , hatener hut gira hishab na kori,nenometre ,hikosecond-e hishab koirbo.Ar baf
Moinu Mia Daka bishobiddaloir holito hodartho biddar mashtor hoi zindegi huru koirbo.
On abar hatener nam Moin Khan.Haten jo-on second year-e hoirto to-on haten hatener
nam hoila serenir magisterate-er tun affidabit kori bodlaisen.Tobe hatener rokte baf dadar
dinna dorzir zei dhara asilo hia roi gase.Ar baf Moin Khan bisshobiddaloi-er sarki sari
garments-er karkhana dise.Garments-er nam “Mirimmoi Apparels”.Mirimmoi ar nam.Bala
nam Mirimmoi,dak nam Miri..Ar baibte bohut khoraf lage ze, bideshi mainshera ar bafer
garments factory-r shirt gai di guri barai.Hatagor gedir loge zei sticker lagi roi,heiane lia Mirimmoi.Aare osin mainsher gar gamer gonde thaikto oi.”
English Translation of the Extract:
“My father’s name is Mainu Mia. It is a very funny name. Only carpenters and tailors
have such names. My grandfather had been a tailor and he named his son in his own way.
He had never dreamt that his son would count in nenometres or picoseconds instead of
counting the inches of cloths to be tailored and my father Mainu Mia would start his life as
a lecturer of Applied Physics at the University of Dhaka.
Now, in fact, his name is Main Khan. When he was a sophomore at the University he
changed his name by making an affidavit from a first class magistrate. However, there
still is the inherent tailorship running along with the flows of his blood . My father Main
Khan quit his job of the University and has established a factory of garments. The name of
the garments’ factory is “Mrimmoi Apparels” .I am Mrimmoi. It is my surname and my
nickname is Mri. Whenever I wonder that the foreigners are wandering around putting on
the shirts of my father’s garments’ industry, I feel sick. My name Mrimmoi is written on the
stickers of the shirts stuck over their shoulders. I have to live in the sweaty stink of the
strangers’ bodies.”
Basing on the following sociolinguistic features of standardization let us start checking out the prospect of standardization of Noakhali dialect:
• Dictionary
• Grammatical Recordings
• System of Pronunciation
• Institutional Back-up
• Legal Status
• Public Use
• Canonized Literature
• Translation
• Teaching Status
• Slectional Status
The status of a standard language requires one or more than one inter-lingual and intra-lingual dictionary that must retain the lexical and orthographic recognition of that language. While converting the presented written extract of Bangla into Noakhali version, beside the autonomy of a genuine speaker of Noakhali in producing the dialect I could not find any dictionary to assist me in this regard. Though a webpage of Banglapedia refers a dictionary named “Ancholic Bhashar Abhidhan” (1965) by Abul Kalam Manjoor Morshed published by Bangla Academy, it presumably gives Noakhali the status of one of the existing dialects of Bangladesh not the assurance of the probable standardization of Noakhali. A closer look of the converted discourse in Noakhali would reveal that there are more variations of this respective dialect at the phonological aspects than in the vocabulary or spelling. Though some distinct vocabulary of Noakhali dialect are there like ‘hut’ of
the Noakhali version of standard Bangla which is ‘chele’ meaning son in English or the Noakhali
‘ashoinna’ for the standard Bangla meaning funny in English, the words bishshabiddaloi,’
‘dorji’,‘kath mistri’ and the others are the same in the standard and Noakhali versions of Bangla
except some allophonic pronunciation variations. As long as no dictionary is there to acknowledge
Noakhali as the standard language and to provide Noakhali equivalents of the total vocabulary of
standard Bangla , the possibility of standardization of Noakhali remains nil in respect of the point of its recognition through a standardized dictionary.
Noakhali dialect does not have any recognized grammar recording. My firsthand experience of transforming a standard written discourse of Bangla into Noakhali discloses that the syntactical formation of it is as syntagmatic as what is in the prescribed grammar of Bangla ratifying the status of Bangla of Nadia region of Bangladesh as the standard one and Noakhali as its regional variety reduced in its status of use.
To make it standardized the pronunciation of a language should attain the recognition of the elite and educated group to be free from regional affects. The phonological features of Noakhali are not independent of the regional distinction as the language of Nadia, which retains the position of being the acrolect of standard Bangla.
No separate authoritative language institution is there for the persistence of the promotion of Noakhali to be the standard language, which is established by the government of Bangladesh.However, it is there for the existing standard variety of Bangla named “Bangla Academy” actively carrying on the publications in larger and smaller scales in promoting the prestige of standard Bangla .
There is no formal use of Noakhali in public-in courts, or in legislature like the existent standard Bangla. It stays as the language of the people of Noakhali region of Bangladesh.After the
transformation into Noakhali of the specimen extract from the novel ‘Mrimmoi’ written in standard Bangla ,the discourse becomes less serious for several readers with an inadvertent tint of humor because of its presupposed reduced pragmatic status in its usage despite the fact that jest is not meant in this respect. A popular entertaining program “Ittadi” of Bangladesh Television (BTV) always incorporate this dialect as the language of its brief comedic pieces which grounds the predisposition of the mass of Bangladesh to consider it a language of farce and fun. No canon literature or vital translation is made in this dialect. It is not taught in schools and is not selected as the standard dialect of exposure for the foreign language (FL) learners of Bangla. The educated, elite, political and influential groups of Bangladesh bearing Noakhali homogeneity or being intrinsically exposed to the socio-cultural phenomenon of Noakhali usually prefer the standard form of Bangla for their wider communication and keep this dialect as their private means of linguistic exchange only with the members of the indigenous community of Noakhali. Hence, no strong political and social support is there to make it the standard language of Bangladesh.
To bring down the curtain, if I started this paper with the mental hypothetical intention of
proving Noakhali dialect’s strong prospects of being the standard language of Bangladesh in some
distant future, my present brisk and handy exploration during the journey of writing down the paper digs out that it does not have any possibility of so.
Bibliography:
1. Ahmed, Humayun.Mrimmoi.Dhaka: Anyaprokash, 2003.
2.Wardhaugh, Ronald.An Introduction to Sociolinguisctis.Oxford: Blackwell, 1986.
3.Richards, J.Platt, J and Weber, H.Longman Dictionary of Applied Linguistics.
UK: Longman, 1985.
4. http://www.banglapedia.com.bd.Online.30 October 2006.
5.http://en.wikipedia.org. Online.30 October 2006.
About the Author
|
|
CAT D3G-XL 2007 System one 20 % track wear $39,900.00 |
|
|
SATABEAST NEXAN One Standard Controller , HP 750G SATA HDD(397377-007) * 42EA $7,800.00 |
|
|
Red Pro Zoom 17-50mm T2.9 PL Mount (F3 5d alexa fs700 red one epic scarlet) $4,900.00 |
|
|
New Custom Gibson Traditional Standard Chambered One-Off Quilted Electric Guitar $4,799.00 |
|
|
One oval standard brilliant cut natural ruby $3,500.00 |
|
|
2011 Gibson one off Custom Shop Standard $3,495.00 |
|
|
SDPL STANDARD Hybrid IPL + TWO Lasers in ONE Compact System Hair, Skin, Tattoos $2,399.95 |
|
|
3KW, 28 V.DC. Generator, w/ 4A032 Miltary Standard Engine – 4 for one Money! $1,750.00 |
|
|
1991 Gibson SG Standard Celebrity w/OHSC! Only Offered One Year! Ebony/Gold! $1,495.00 |
|
|
Polly Products Standard Picnic Table ADA One End – ASM-SPT2HA-02 $1,259.99 |
|
|
Polly Products Standard Picnic Table ADA One Ends – Brown with Black Frame $1,259.99 |
|
|
Polly Products Standard Picnic Table ADA One Ends – Cedar with Black Frame $1,259.99 |
|
|
Polly Products Standard Picnic Table ADA One Ends – Green with Black Frame $1,259.99 |
|
|
Polly Products Standard Picnic Table ADA One Ends – Grey with Black Frame $1,259.99 |
|
|
Polly Products Standard Picnic Table ADA One Ends – Sand with Black Frame $1,259.99 |
|
|
Polly Products Standard Picnic Table ADA One Ends – Weathered with Black Frame $1,259.99 |
|
|
Polly Products Standard Picnic Table ADA One Ends – Brown with Brown Frame $1,259.99 |
|
|
Polly Products Standard Picnic Table ADA One Ends – Cedar with Brown Frame $1,259.99 |
|
|
Polly Products Standard Picnic Table ADA One Ends – Green with Brown Frame $1,259.99 |
|
|
Polly Products Standard Picnic Table ADA One Ends – Grey with Brown Frame $1,259.99 |
|
|
Polly Products Standard Picnic Table ADA One Ends – Sand with Brown Frame $1,259.99 |
|
|
Polly Products Standard Picnic Table ADA One Ends – Weathered with Brown Frame $1,259.99 |
|
|
Polly Products Standard Picnic Table ADA One Ends – Cedar with Green Frame $1,259.99 |
|
|
Polly Products Standard Picnic Table ADA One Ends – Green with Green Frame $1,259.99 |
|
|
Polly Products Standard Picnic Table ADA One Ends – Sand with Green Frame $1,259.99 |
|
|
Polly Products Standard Picnic Table ADA One Ends – Weathered with Green Frame $1,259.99 |
|
|
Polly Products Standard Picnic Table ADA One Ends – Grey with Green Frame $1,259.99 |
|
|
Polly Products Standard Picnic Table ADA One End – ASM-SPTHA-02 $1,219.99 |
|
|
Polly Products Standard Picnic Table ADA One End – Brown with Black Frame $1,219.99 |
|
|
Polly Products Standard Picnic Table ADA One End – Cedar with Black Frame $1,219.99 |
|
|
Polly Products Standard Picnic Table ADA One End – Grey with Black Frame $1,219.99 |
|
|
Polly Products Standard Picnic Table ADA One End – Sand with Black Frame $1,219.99 |
|
|
Polly Products Standard Picnic Table ADA One End – Green with Black Frame $1,219.99 |
|
|
Polly Products Standard Picnic Table ADA One End – Brown with Brown Frame $1,219.99 |
|
|
Polly Products Standard Picnic Table ADA One End – Weathered with Black Frame $1,219.99 |
|
|
Polly Products Standard Picnic Table ADA One End – Cedar with Brown Frame $1,219.99 |
|
|
Polly Products Standard Picnic Table ADA One End – Green with Brown Frame $1,219.99 |
|
|
Polly Products Standard Picnic Table ADA One End – Grey with Brown Frame $1,219.99 |
|
|
Polly Products Standard Picnic Table ADA One End – Sand with Brown Frame $1,219.99 |
|
|
Polly Products Standard Picnic Table ADA One End – Weathered with Brown Frame $1,219.99 |
|
|
Polly Products Standard Picnic Table ADA One End – Cedar with Green Frame $1,219.99 |
|
|
Polly Products Standard Picnic Table ADA One End – Grey with Green Frame $1,219.99 |
|
|
Polly Products Standard Picnic Table ADA One End – Sand with Green Frame $1,219.99 |
|
|
Polly Products Standard Picnic Table ADA One End – Green with Green Frame $1,219.99 |
|
|
Polly Products Standard Picnic Table ADA One End – Weathered with Green Frame $1,219.99 |
|
|
Renishaw TP20 CMM Touch Probe kit One Standard Force Stylus Module with Warranty $1,050.00 |
|
|
3KW, 28 V.DC. Generator, w/ 4A032 Miltary Standard Engine – 2 for one Money! $1,000.00 |
|
|
Military Standard Engine Model 2A042! New in Crate! 2 For One Money! $950.00 |
|
|
Hot Rat Rod Mustang II Power Front Suspension Kit $949.00 |
|
|
Hot Rat Street Rod Mustang II Front Suspension Kit $949.00 |
|
|
Vinturi Essential Wine Aerator Wine needs to breathe to allow it to open up, release its intended aromas, and of course, make it taste better. Vinturi’s patent pending design speeds up this process by instantly aerating with ease and convenience. The perfect aeration in the time it takes to pour a glass of wine…. |
|
|
Progressive GT-3520 International 19-Piece Measuring Cup and Spoon Set $6.99 19 Piece, Measuring Set, Includes: 10 Measuring Cups & 9 Measuring Spoons, Dishwasher Safe…. |
|
|
Ball Mouth Plastic Storage Caps Ball Regular Mouth Plastic Storage Caps… |
|
|
Michael Buble $5.17 CD > POPULAR MUSIC > ROCK… |
|
|
Unchained Melody: Very Best Of The Righteous Brothers $2.25 No Description Available.Genre: Popular MusicMedia Format: Compact DiskRating: Release Date: 15-JAN-1991… |
|
|
Glee: The Music – Dance Party $9.98 Glee: The Music – Dance Party contains six songs from the hit show Glee. Track listing: 1. I’m A Slave 4 U 2. I Know What Boys Like 3. Blame It (On The Alcohol) 4. Tik Tok 5. I’m Not Gonna Teach Your Boyfriend How To Dance With You 6. Yeah!… |
|
|
Sleeping Beauty (Two-Disc Platinum Edition Blu-ray/DVD Combo + BD Live) [Blu-ray] $31.65 Disney’s 1959 animated effort was the studio’s most ambitious to date, a widescreen spectacle boasting a gorgeous waltz-filled score adapting Tchaikovsky. In the 14th century, the malevolent Maleficent (not dissimilar to the wicked Queen in Disney’s Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs taunts a king that his infant Aurora will fatally prick her finger on a spinning wheel before sundown on her 16th birt… |
|
|
Bambi (Two-Disc Diamond Edition Blu-ray/DVD Combo in Blu-ray Packaging) $22.50 It always comes up when people are comparing their most traumatic movie experiences: “the death of Bambi’s mother,” a recollection that can bring a shudder to even the most jaded filmgoer. That primal separation (which is no less stunning for happening off-screen) is the centerpiece of Bambi, Walt Disney’s 1942 animated classic, but it is by no means the only bold stroke in the film. In its swift … |
|
|
Up (Four-Disc Blu-ray/DVD Combo + BD Live) [Blu-ray] $23.50 Features include: •MPAA Rating: PG•Format: Blu-Ray•Runtime: 96 minutes… |
|
|
Original UK Version Part Two $1.99 … |